When intended parents first begin researching surrogacy, one of the questions they may encounter is whether they need to work with a surrogacy agency at all.
Could you find a surrogate yourself? What if a friend or family member has already offered to carry for you? Would an independent or “private” surrogacy cost less? And if you do not use an agency, who handles screening, attorneys, escrow, insurance, medical appointments, and all the other pieces of the journey?
The answer is that both independent surrogacy and agency-supported surrogacy can result in successful journeys.
The difference is largely about who finds the match, who coordinates the process, and who assumes responsibility for making sure all of the moving parts stay organized.
At Simple Surrogacy, we have coordinated surrogacy journeys since 2002, including journeys for intended parents who come to us needing a surrogate and journeys for intended parents who have already found someone they want to work with.
That experience has taught us something important:
Even when you remove the agency from a surrogacy journey, you do not remove the need for professional screening, medical care, psychological preparation, independent legal representation, insurance review, financial management, and careful coordination.
The real question is whether you want to assemble and manage those pieces yourself or have an experienced agency coordinate them for you.
Independent surrogacy—sometimes called private surrogacy—is a surrogacy journey completed without a full-service surrogacy agency managing the process.
In many independent journeys, the intended parents already know their surrogate. She may be a friend, relative, acquaintance, or someone they met independently.
This is often referred to as a known surrogate, identified surrogate, or directed surrogate arrangement.
Other intended parents attempt to find a surrogate on their own through personal networks, online groups, social media, or other sources and then assemble the professionals needed to complete the journey.
Independent does not mean informal.
A gestational-surrogacy arrangement still involves fertility medicine, screening, psychological evaluation, contracts, insurance, escrow, parentage, and other professional services.
The difference is that without an agency, the intended parents and surrogate generally take greater responsibility for identifying those providers, communicating between them, tracking deadlines, managing logistics, and resolving problems when they arise.
A full-service surrogacy agency serves as the central coordinator of the journey.
The exact services vary considerably among agencies, which is why intended parents should always ask what an agency fee actually includes.
At Simple Surrogacy, our current intended-parent program includes services such as surrogate recruitment, matching, background screening, psychological evaluation, insurance review, coordination with fertility clinics and attorneys, travel coordination, escrow oversight, birth planning, ongoing case management, mediation, and support throughout the journey.
You can see a more detailed breakdown of our current program and what is included on our Surrogacy Fees and Costs page.
An agency does not replace the other professionals involved.
Your fertility clinic is still responsible for reproductive medical care.
Your attorney still represents your legal interests.
Your surrogate should have her own independent attorney.
A qualified mental-health professional conducts psychological evaluations.
An independent escrow company should manage funds intended for surrogate compensation and expenses.
The agency’s role is to help coordinate those professionals and keep the overall journey moving.
| Independent Surrogacy | Agency-Supported Surrogacy | |
|---|---|---|
| Finding a surrogate | Usually handled by intended parents or through an existing relationship | Agency recruits and facilitates matching |
| Initial screening | Intended parents must arrange appropriate screening | Agency typically coordinates pre-screening |
| Medical screening | Fertility clinic | Fertility clinic, with agency coordination |
| Psychological evaluation | Must be independently arranged | Typically coordinated by agency |
| Attorneys | Parties locate and retain their own counsel | Agency typically provides experienced referrals and coordinates timing |
| Escrow | Parties arrange an independent escrow provider | Agency typically coordinates establishment and funding |
| Insurance review | Intended parents arrange specialized review | Usually coordinated by agency |
| Communication | Managed directly between parties | Agency can help facilitate communication |
| Journey logistics | Primarily managed by intended parents and surrogate | Case coordinator manages deadlines and moving pieces |
| Problems or conflict | Parties must determine who can help mediate | Agency can act as an experienced intermediary |
| Agency fee | Usually none | Yes |
| Professional third-party costs | Still required | Still required |
The important point is that independent surrogacy may eliminate an agency fee, but it does not eliminate most of the other professional expenses involved in a properly structured journey.
Potentially.
If intended parents already know their surrogate and are comfortable coordinating the journey themselves, eliminating a full-service agency fee can reduce the overall cost.
But it is important to compare the correct numbers.
Independent surrogacy does not mean eliminating the cost of:
Those costs exist regardless of whether an agency is involved.
When comparing independent and agency-assisted surrogacy, look specifically at what services the agency fee replaces or coordinates, rather than comparing an agency journey with an unrealistic version of independent surrogacy in which professional safeguards have been removed.
Our Surrogacy Fees and Costs page provides a detailed look at the different categories of expenses intended parents may encounter.
Not necessarily.
Some intended parents have a trusted friend or family member who has volunteered to carry for them and are comfortable assembling the professional team themselves.
That can be a reasonable option.
But knowing your surrogate does not eliminate the need for appropriate screening.
In fact, professional guidance recognizes that even when the intended parents and surrogate have a pre-existing relationship, they should still go through the appropriate psychological and legal process.
A close friendship can sometimes make difficult conversations more complicated, not less.
What happens if the screening process identifies a concern?
How will compensation and expenses be handled?
What happens if someone changes their mind?
What if the intended parents and surrogate disagree about prenatal testing?
What kind of contact will everyone have after delivery?
How will the existing friendship or family relationship be affected?
These conversations can feel awkward precisely because the people involved already care about each other.
An independent mental-health professional and experienced reproductive attorneys can help everyone discuss these questions before treatment begins.
One area where intended parents should be particularly cautious is screening.
If someone you love has offered to carry your baby, it can feel uncomfortable to ask her to undergo psychological evaluation, background screening, medical-record review, and fertility-clinic testing.
But screening is not an accusation that someone is untrustworthy.
It is part of determining whether surrogacy is medically, psychologically, and practically appropriate.
The American Society for Reproductive Medicine recommends medical evaluation, psychosocial evaluation and counseling, infectious-disease testing, and legal counseling as part of gestational-carrier arrangements.
Importantly, ASRM states that psychological evaluation and counseling are appropriate for both directed/known gestational carriers and agency-recruited carriers.
If you want to understand what happens when a potential surrogate reaches the fertility-clinic screening stage, read our Surrogacy 101: Medical Screening guide.
Whether you use an agency or pursue surrogacy independently, intended parents and the surrogate should not simply download a contract online or use one attorney for everyone.
The intended parents need legal counsel representing their interests.
The surrogate needs independent counsel representing hers.
Surrogacy laws vary by state, and the location of the intended parents, surrogate, fertility clinic, and anticipated delivery can all matter.
The agreement may address issues including compensation and expenses, insurance, medical decisions, prenatal testing, embryo transfer, pregnancy expectations, communication, confidentiality, delivery, parentage, and potential complications.
ASRM recommends independent legal representation and a fully executed legal agreement before treatment begins.
Our Surrogacy 101: The Legal Process explains this stage in more detail.
Whether a journey is agency-assisted or independent, money intended for a surrogate’s compensation and reimbursable expenses should be handled carefully.
At Simple Surrogacy, we believe surrogate funds should be maintained through independent escrow rather than held by the agency itself.
That separation protects both intended parents and surrogates.
If you pursue an independent journey, you will need to identify an experienced escrow provider, establish the account according to the legal agreement, ensure it is adequately funded, and make sure payments and reimbursements are administered correctly.
This is one of the many responsibilities intended parents take on when removing a coordinating agency from the process.
This is probably the biggest practical difference between the two approaches.
A surrogacy journey can involve:
Those professionals do not necessarily communicate directly with one another about every detail.
Someone has to know what has been completed, what is still outstanding, who needs documentation, whether escrow has been funded, whether medical clearance has been issued, whether legal clearance has reached the clinic, and what happens next.
In an agency journey, much of that coordination becomes the agency’s responsibility.
In an independent journey, the intended parents and surrogate assume much more of it themselves.
Our Surrogacy Process Overview for Intended Parents gives you an idea of how many separate stages and professionals may be involved from the first consultation through delivery.
This is an important question that is sometimes overlooked when people compare agency fees.
Most surrogacy journeys involve long periods when everything proceeds normally.
The real value of experience often becomes clearer when something does not.
A potential surrogate may fail medical screening.
A match may end.
A transfer may be cancelled.
An embryo transfer may not result in pregnancy.
Insurance coverage may change.
A provider may submit an unexpected bill.
The intended parents and surrogate may misunderstand each other’s expectations.
A pregnancy complication may arise.
An attorney, clinic, or escrow provider may need information quickly.
If you are working independently, you need to decide who will coordinate the response.
A good agency provides a neutral, experienced party who already understands the history of the journey and can help communicate among everyone involved.
That does not mean an agency can eliminate complications.
It means you are not necessarily figuring out how to manage them for the first time while they are happening.
Even when intended parents and a surrogate have an excellent relationship, financial and logistical conversations can create tension.
A surrogate should not have to repeatedly ask intended parents directly whether an expense has been reimbursed.
Intended parents should not have to worry that asking a logistical question will feel personal.
And neither side should have to become the sole mediator when expectations are misunderstood.
A coordinator can create some healthy separation between the relationship and the administration of the journey.
That becomes particularly valuable during stressful moments.
Independent surrogacy may be worth considering when:
For some families, particularly those with an identified surrogate, this model can work very well.
Agency-supported surrogacy may be especially valuable when:
Working with an agency costs more than doing the agency’s work yourself.
The question is whether the services, experience, time, screening, coordination, and support justify that cost for your particular journey.
The choice does not always have to be either completely independent or completely agency-matched.
Some intended parents find their own surrogate but still want professional help screening her and coordinating the journey.
Simple Surrogacy works with intended parents in exactly this situation.
If you bring your own gestational surrogate into our program, we can coordinate the screening and journey while eliminating the need for us to recruit and match you with someone.
Our current fee structure provides a $10,000 agency-fee discount for intended parents who bring their own surrogate.
You can see the current details on our Surrogacy Fees page.
For some families, this hybrid approach provides the best of both options: you already have the relationship, while experienced professionals help manage the process around it.
Before deciding between independent and agency-supported surrogacy, ask yourself:
Do we already have a surrogate?
If not, how will you find and evaluate candidates?
Who will arrange screening?
Who will collect medical records, coordinate psychological evaluation, handle background checks, review insurance, and make sure the fertility clinic receives what it needs?
Who will manage the timeline?
Are you comfortable tracking several professionals and multiple stages over what may be a year or longer?
Who will handle money?
How will independent escrow be established and administered?
What happens if there is a conflict?
Who acts as a neutral intermediary?
What happens if our surrogate does not pass screening?
Will you start searching again on your own?
What happens if a transfer fails or the match ends?
Who determines the next steps?
What services are we actually getting for an agency fee?
Do not assume all agencies provide the same services.
If you decide an agency makes sense for your family, our guide to Choosing a Surrogacy Agency explains what to look for when comparing agencies.
Not in every situation. The requirements governing surrogacy depend on the states and circumstances involved. Even when an agency is not required, professional medical care, appropriate screening, independent legal representation, and proper financial arrangements remain important.
Potentially, provided she meets appropriate medical and psychological criteria and the arrangement is legally appropriate. A pre-existing relationship should not be used as a reason to skip professional screening or independent attorneys.
It may reduce agency-related costs, especially when intended parents have already found their surrogate. However, medical, legal, psychological, escrow, insurance, surrogate compensation, fertility-treatment, and pregnancy-related expenses still exist.
Yes. Trust and legal protection serve different purposes. Intended parents and surrogates should have independent representation from attorneys experienced in assisted-reproduction law.
Professional guidance recommends psychological evaluation and counseling for gestational carriers regardless of whether they were recruited through an agency or already knew the intended parents.
Yes. Some agencies, including Simple Surrogacy, work with intended parents who bring an identified surrogate and want professional screening and coordination rather than matching services.
For many intended parents, it is having one experienced team responsible for coordinating the many separate professionals, requirements, deadlines, and relationships involved in the journey.
Independent surrogacy is not inherently irresponsible, and agency-supported surrogacy is not automatically right for every family.
The important distinction is between removing unnecessary layers and removing safeguards.
If you pursue surrogacy independently, build a qualified professional team around the journey and understand which responsibilities you will be assuming yourself.
If you choose an agency, understand exactly what the agency provides and whether its approach to screening, matching, escrow, communication, and support aligns with your priorities.
At Simple Surrogacy, we have been coordinating journeys since 2002, and we work with intended parents both when they need us to find a surrogate and when they have already found someone special who wants to carry for them.
If you are trying to decide which approach makes sense for your family, contact Simple Surrogacy for an intended-parent consultation. We are happy to explain what professional coordination includes, what you would need to manage independently, and which pieces of the process apply to your particular situation.
Go backSurrogacy 101: Becoming an Intended Parent Through Surrogacy Becoming an intended parent through surrogacy can feel exciting, hopeful—and, at first, a little overwhelming. Most people begin the process with far more questions than answers. Do you need embryos before contacting…
Lern more →Why Surrogates Should Think Twice Before Choosing an Agency That Also Represents the Intended Parents Choosing a surrogacy agency is one of the most important decisions a gestational carrier will make during her journey. Your agency is often the central…
Lern more →Surrogacy Pregnancy and Delivery: What Intended Parents and Surrogates Should Expect Quick Summary Once an embryo transfer results in an established pregnancy, a surrogacy journey enters a very different stage. The fertility clinic eventually releases the gestational surrogate to her…
Lern more →
